Navigating College Conversations This Holiday Season
By Director of College Counseling Sandra Sohne-Johnston, P. ’27
Whether you’re gathering with extended family, catching up with old friends, or spending time with a smaller circle, college will likely come up. Everyone has a different comfort level with how much they want to share. The guidance below can help you navigate these conversations with confidence and ease.
Advice for Seniors
In “The College Applicant’s Guide to Holiday Season Serenity,” Forbes Education Contributor Brennan Barnard states that admissions leaders share great strategies for steering holiday conversations toward topics you actually enjoy. A few quick tactics:
Flip the script
Ask relatives about their own lives, jobs, or favorite memories to redirect the spotlight.
Hang out with younger cousins or siblings
They won’t ask about your college list.
Keep a short, authentic deflection ready
Practice a warm response that answers the question without inviting an interrogation.

Quick Scripts for Common Questions
“Where did you apply?”
“I’m still finalizing my list, but I’m looking at a mix of schools in [region/type].”
“I’m excited about the variety of options I have.”
“What about you? Did you always know where you wanted to go, or did you apply to a bunch of places too?”
“What’s your first choice?” or “Where are you going next year?”
“Honestly, I’m really happy with all the schools on my list, so I’m trying not to get too attached to one until I see where I get in.”
“Did you have a dream school when you were applying, or did you keep an open mind?”
“What do you want to major in?”
“I’m interested in [general area], but I’m keeping my options open.”
“Part of college is exploring things I haven’t had a chance to study yet.”
“What did you end up majoring in? Did you stick with it or switch halfway through?”
“Did you apply early anywhere?”
“My counselor encouraged us to apply early to a few schools, so it feels good to have some submitted already.”
“How do you usually handle big deadlines? Are you an early bird or a last-minute person?”
For Parents and Guardians
In What NOT to Discuss at the Holiday Table, E. Whitney Soule, vice provost and dean of admissions at the University of Pennsylvania, shares three essential reminders for protecting your student’s headspace:
Don’t prioritize others’ curiosity over your child’s privacy.
Your senior may not want to broadcast where they applied, and that’s okay.
You can politely deflect: “We’re keeping the details private for now, but we’re really proud of the work they’ve put in.”
Don’t let others dominate the table with admissions sagas.
Well-meaning relatives often spiral into stories about their own kids’ processes.
Redirect with: “Every student’s path is unique. We’re just focused on supporting ours through theirs.”
Don’t let family members apply outdated standards.
Today’s admissions landscape looks nothing like it did twenty or thirty years ago.
A gentle reminder works wonders: “The process has changed a lot since we applied. We’re just taking it one step at a time.”
(Want a few more ways to take the focus off your senior? Check out fellow independent school counselor Bartley Sides‘ fun piece on the ACCIS Blog: Six Easy Ways to Earn MVP on Turkey Day.)
Protecting Your Student’s Confidence
Comments like “If I were you, I’d choose [School X]” or “I thought you’d aim higher” can quietly chip away at a senior’s confidence. As Christopher Gruber, VP and dean of admissions and financial aid at Davidson College, reminds us in “College Admission Leaders Share Tips for Talking to Teens at the Holidays“:
Let them know early that they are loved, that you are proud of them, and that you have every confidence in them in finding the next academic home that will be right for them.
— Christopher Gruber